Death and the Compass (1996)
Death and the Compass (Alex Cox, 1996)

Originally conceived as a 50 minute made-for-television film for Spanish TV/BBC in 1992, British filmmaker Alex Cox (Repo Man, Sid & Nancy) later expanded the film into a 96-minute feature. The film, which is adapted from the Jorge Luis Borges short story La Muerte y La Brujula, was Cox's second Mexican feature, and it is probably no coincidence that it is representative (if not obvious influence) of Luis Bunuel. In the film, Cox paints Borges' other-worldly vision of a crime-filled dystopia onto a stunning visual canvas of endlessly bright blues and yellows, long takes, and jump cuts, combined with muddled field recordings and an 80s-style synthesizer-filled soundtrack from Pray for Rain.
The story is all at once simple and vastly complex. The film is narrated in the present by Treviranus (Miguel Sandoval), who hysterically recalls the past downfall of the city's greatest detective, Erik Lonrot (Peter Boyle). A self professed rationalist, Lonrot begins investigating the murder of a Rabbi, and with the help of a Zunz (Christopher Eccleston), a nerdy journalist, he subsequently (and inaccurately) begins his symbolic, religious text-driven search to unmask a conspiracy involving the notoriously evil crime lord Red Scarlach. All of this, of course, is done against the advice of his commander, Treviranus, who gives us this story with a large amount of comical hysteria, pain, jealously, and sadness.
The strong visual style carries the film, and the plot unfolds (although clumsily) as a somewhat standard mystery (though absurd) -- though from what I've gathered about the Borges short story (I'm not this perceptive) is that it is often viewed as an allegory for the reading/misreading of text (i.e. Lonrot's impossible investigation), and the exploration of the relationship between truth, perception, and symbolism makes it a bit more interesting -- though it didn't really cross my mind upon viewing. Despite it's boots being stuck in the mud of not only Borges, but the film detective genre itself, Death and the Compass nobly leaves its Wellington's behind and ventures (in socks!) into a nightmarish mess of saturated colors and orgasmic surrealism. Cox makes the film his own, though at what price I'm not sure -- it's brilliant to look at and is comical in its own dark, off-beat way, but it comes across as a bit thin (and quite possibly lazy). Who knows though, maybe I'm just misreading it.
With wonderful cinematography by Miguel Garzon, jarring editing by Carlos Puente, and elaborate set design by Cecilia Montiel. 96 minutes. B&W and Color.
Links:
-Alex Cox on Death and the Compass
-Los Angeles Times review by Kevin Thomas
-Brief review from The Garden of Forking Paths
-Literary essay about the short story by Matei Calinescu
















